I Spent Two Years Automating Trading Strategies. Here Is What I Learned About the Forex Market.
I have been trading for some time. Throughout 2024, I spent most of my time trading, learning, and studying charts. Like most beginners, I focused heavily on technical analysis. I believed that if I could understand price action well enough, I could develop a strategy that would consistently make money.
Coming from a strong technical background as a software engineer, I eventually had what I thought was a brilliant idea: Why not automate the entire trading process and build my own money-making machine?
That decision changed my entire perspective on trading.
The Problem With the Strategies I Had Learned
Automating my trading strategies exposed flaws that I would probably never have discovered through manual trading alone.
I started writing trading algorithms, backtesting strategies, and evaluating their performance over historical market data. What I discovered was both frustrating and enlightening.
None of the strategies I had learned worked consistently over the long term.
Some strategies appeared profitable for a year or two. Their backtests looked promising, and their performance gave me enough confidence to believe I had found something valuable. However, when I tested them against five, seven, or more years of historical data, the results were often disastrous.
The strategies that seemed to work eventually broke down.
This raised an important question: Were these strategies actually exploiting something meaningful in the market, or were they simply taking advantage of temporary market conditions?
I spent the entirety of 2025 trying to find answers.
2025: A Year of Automating My Trading Strategies
I dedicated the whole of 2025 to automating my trading strategies.
I wrote MT5 scripts, developed Expert Advisors, set up Windows servers, and built systems to execute and test my trading ideas. Since MetaTrader 5 runs natively on Windows, I had to work with Windows-based infrastructure to run my trading bots.
My approach was straightforward: if I could identify a profitable trading strategy, I could automate it, eliminate human emotions, and let the system do the work.
But reality was very different.
I watched my bots execute trades and lose money. Price moved in almost every direction except the one my strategies anticipated. Setups that looked perfect on the charts failed repeatedly.
The more I automated, the more I realised how much I didn't understand about the market.
1. Most Trading Strategies You Find Online Are Not What They Seem
One of my biggest realisations was that many of the trading strategies presented online are far less reliable than they appear.
I don't mean that every strategy shared online is useless. Rather, the problem is that many strategies are presented without sufficient context about the market conditions in which they work, their limitations, or their long-term performance.
A strategy can look incredibly profitable on a chart. It can even produce impressive backtest results over a short period. But that doesn't necessarily mean it has a durable edge.
My automated systems made this painfully clear.
However, the experience was not a waste.
I learned how to extract information from charts. I learned how to develop and test trading strategies independently. I no longer needed to rely on YouTube videos to come up with trading ideas.
I had developed the ability to formulate my own hypotheses, translate them into code, and test whether they held up against historical data.
That was a major step forward.
Yet, despite all these improvements, something was still missing.
There was a missing link—something I hadn't fully understood about the market. My technical strategies could identify patterns, structures, and potential entries, but they couldn't adequately explain why price would move in one direction rather than another.
I needed to understand what was actually driving the market.
2. I Lost My Funded Account and Rethought Prop Firm Trading
At some point, I lost my funded account with Goat Funded.
That experience forced me to reconsider my approach to prop firm trading.
I had spent time, effort, and money trying to pass a prop firm challenge, only to eventually lose the account. The economics of the process began to make less sense to me.
Why go through the stress of passing a challenge, meeting all the requirements, and securing a funded account, only to risk losing it later?
I decided I would no longer trade prop firm accounts.
Instead, I wanted to develop a trading approach that I could execute on my own account, with a better understanding of the underlying market dynamics.
3. I Moved to Synthetic Indices, Then Came Back to Forex
After leaving prop firm trading, I focused on synthetic indices.
I traded them for a considerable period, developing and testing strategies specifically for those markets. However, over time, I became increasingly concerned about their market mechanics and the extent to which their price movements could be influenced by the provider's design.
I eventually decided to move away from synthetic indices.
I returned to Forex, but this time with a completely different mindset.
I was no longer interested in simply finding another technical strategy. I wanted to understand the fundamental forces that drive currency prices.
And that is where my perspective began to change significantly.
The Missing Link: Understanding Fundamentals
My biggest realisation so far is that fundamentals are a major driver of Forex currencies.
Technical analysis can help us understand price structure, identify potential entries, and manage trades. But when it comes to understanding why a currency is strengthening or weakening over an extended period, fundamentals become incredibly important.
Currencies don't move in isolation.
They are influenced by interest rates, inflation, central bank policies, economic growth, employment data, capital flows, geopolitical developments, and market expectations.
A currency pair is also a relative instrument. When trading EURUSD, for example, you are not simply betting on the euro. You are evaluating the euro against the US dollar.
This means that understanding the strength or weakness of one currency is not enough. You need to understand both sides of the pair and how their underlying economic conditions compare.
I have come to believe that there is a more systematic way to approach this.
There is a way to identify the currencies likely to strengthen or weaken over the coming days, weeks, or months. There is a way to estimate how long a particular trend might persist, identify the conditions that could interrupt it, and recognise when the underlying drivers are changing.
The key is understanding the fundamental drivers, how long they are likely to remain relevant, and what could cause the trend to continue, pause, or reverse.
You cannot simply pick a currency pair because it looks good on a chart.
You need to understand why that pair should move in a particular direction in the first place.
When the Market Trends, Almost Every Strategy Works
Here is another observation from my trading journey:
When the market is trending, almost every trading strategy works.
Think about it.
During a strong bullish trend, a trader using moving averages might make money. A trader using price action might make money. Someone trading breakouts, pullbacks, or even simple support and resistance might also make money.
Different strategies can produce profitable results because they are all, in one way or another, trading in the direction of the prevailing trend.
The real challenge is not finding an entry strategy.
The real challenge is identifying when the market is likely to trend, which direction it is likely to move, and when that trend is likely to end.
This is where I believe many traders spend too much time focusing on entries and too little time understanding the broader market environment.
A good entry strategy cannot consistently compensate for trading against a strong underlying market force.
What I Am Building Now
I am currently working on automating this entire process.
My goal is to build a tool that does more than identify chart patterns or generate buy and sell signals.
I want to build a system that helps make the important decisions before a trade is even considered.
A system that can:
- Identify the currencies with the strongest and weakest fundamental outlooks.
- Determine which Forex pairs are worth paying attention to.
- Identify the fundamental drivers behind a currency's current direction.
- Evaluate how long those drivers are likely to remain relevant.
- Recognise potential interruptions to an existing trend.
- Identify conditions that support trend continuation.
- Detect when the underlying market environment is changing.
- Use technical analysis to determine appropriate trade entries and exits.
In essence, I want to build a system that answers the most important questions a Forex trader should be asking:
Which currency should I be trading?
Why should I be trading it?
How long is the underlying reason for this trade likely to remain valid?
What could cause the trade to fail?
When should I stop trading in that direction?
I am still working on it. I don't have all the answers yet, and I am not claiming to have discovered a guaranteed way to make money in the Forex market.
But I believe I am asking better questions now.
Conclusion
My journey into trading automation has been one of the most educational experiences of my life.
It has taught me that being able to code a trading strategy is not the same as understanding the market. A strategy can be technically sound, beautifully implemented, and profitable in a backtest, yet still fail because it does not account for the forces driving price.
I started this journey looking for a money-making machine.
I am now focused on understanding the market well enough to build a system that makes informed decisions.
The goal is no longer just to automate trades.
The goal is to understand why those trades should exist in the first place.
And that, I believe, is where the real work begins.